Skip to main content

The Best Boutique Hotels with Pool in Edgartown, MV in 2026

> Our Methodology

Got Fixed Dates? Let’s have them!

{“hide_search_input”:false,”hide_near_input”:true,”show”:””,”filters_pos”:””,”input_size”:””,”bar_flex_wrap”:””,”bar_flex_wrap_md”:””,”bar_flex_wrap_lg”:””,”input_border”:””,”input_border_opacity”:””,”input_rounded_size”:””,”btn_bg”:””,”btn_rounded_size”:””,”btn_rounded_size_md”:””,”btn_rounded_size_lg”:”0″,”bg”:””,”mt”:””,”mr”:”n1″,”mb”:”4″,”ml”:”n1″,”pt”:””,”pr”:”0″,”pb”:””,”pl”:”0″,”border”:””,”rounded”:””,”rounded_size”:””,”rounded_size_md”:””,”rounded_size_lg”:””,”shadow”:””,”css_class”:””}
> Jump to map view
9516537 768x527

Martha’s Vineyard

327360273 768x432

Harbor View Hotel

Show on the Map
Listed in: The Best Boutique Hotels in New England in 2026
Number of Rooms: 114
Guide Price: Between $200 & $300 per Night
Show Prices
Address: 131 North Water Street
Edgartown, MV
Martha’s Vineyard
Massachusetts
02539
Compare it with others in: Boutique Hotels For Families, Luxury Boutique Hotels, and Boutique Hotels with Pool
This super-classic seaside resort is a Martha’s Vineyard stalwart, set on the edge of Edgartown spitting distance from the lighthouse. Sure, we’re suckers for a hidden gem or a homey boutique B&B, but sometimes you just want to stay somewhere that feels both intimate and solidly, unarguably luxurious. Harbor View Hotel is one of those. The turn-of-the-century building sits imperiously on a corner, very clearly the hallmark of local accommodation. It’s one of a few that stays open all year, which is a huge plus. If you’re willing to brave… > Read Our Full Review