5 Best, Genuine Boutique Hotels in Marthas Vineyard in 2026

On the boutique hotel scene, Martha’s Vineyard is Lark Hotels territory, and their Edgartown Collection again shows why this brand has taken off throughout New England. The Edgartown Inn, top of the collection, offers everything you might want from a Cape and islands vacation. You’ve got the renovated whaling captain’s house, surrounded by historic buildings, and there’s even a lighthouse in walking distance. The hospitality is straightforward homely B&B, though the muted upscale decor feels like it belongs to your mom’s friend who’s on the board of the local environmental… > Read Our Full Review

Sure, everyone loves an old ship captain’s house full of antiques, linen and wicker deck furniture, but we’re all happy that Edgartown has something a bit more contemporary. Another gem from Lark Hotels, this funky-chic boutique hotel from the brand’s Edgartown Collection is a breath of fresh air among the salty breezes of Martha’s Vineyard. There are plenty of places that manage to balance contemporary and historical flair, and we love that The Sydney doesn’t try. Forget reclaimed wood, white and blue, and antique botanical prints. Here, you’ve got colorfully… > Read Our Full Review

This super-classic seaside resort is a Martha’s Vineyard stalwart, set on the edge of Edgartown spitting distance from the lighthouse. Sure, we’re suckers for a hidden gem or a homey boutique B&B, but sometimes you just want to stay somewhere that feels both intimate and solidly, unarguably luxurious. Harbor View Hotel is one of those. The turn-of-the-century building sits imperiously on a corner, very clearly the hallmark of local accommodation. It’s one of a few that stays open all year, which is a huge plus. If you’re willing to brave… > Read Our Full Review

Lark Hotel’s Edgartown Collection is a group of five boutique hotels that offer different takes on Martha’s Vineyard hospitality. The Christopher makes our top three by feeling the most like the brand itself. Known for chic design that may or may not lean towards the twee, you can trust a Lark hotel for on-point design and attention to detail. This is no exception. It’s an elegant white building, registered historical, with gorgeous arches, top-floor balconies, and a sweet blue sign that hints at the charm of the interior. Inside, it’s… > Read Our Full Review

This Oak Bluffs boutique hotel is just the kind of nontraditional experience you want to make a trip to Martha’s Vineyard remarkable. Another supremely cute offering from New England hotel powerhouse Lark Hotels, Summercamp is a bright, sunny way to spend a vacation with your inner child. With a vision that is perhaps a little more convoluted than the occasion calls for, the idea is that, if the Methodists used to use Martha’s Vineyard as a summer camp, why can’t the Millennials? And even if we don’t want to be… > Read Our Full Review